Monday, December 16, 2019

Book Review: Dragon Pearl

Warning: This review contains significant spoilers. If that's a thing you care about, suffice it to say that if you exist, I think you should read this book.

I read a lot of fiction by and about marginalized people, and a lot of it, while very good, feels a little bit like "This ought to have existed like 20 years ago". Dragon Pearl by Yoon Ha Lee both does and does not fall into this category. I feel like something like Dragon Pearl ought to have existed long before now, but perhaps only only so  I could say "Not your average gender exploratory early YA/late Middle Grade novel inspired by Korean mythology."

Premise
In the far future, humans and a few other creatures, including goblins and dragons, have widely colonized space. Protagonist Min lives on the neglected planet Jinju with her extended family, all of whom are Gumiho, fox spirits. When her brother Jun is accused of deserting the Space Forces, she embarks on a journey to solve his disappearance, prove his innocence, and find the Dragon Pearl, a long-lost artifact with the power to control the weather and terraform planets. Her journey leads her to impersonate a cadet on the ship her brother left, and eventually leads her and her friends to a showdown on a forbidden planet, the solution to which relies more on compassion and creativity than it does on action and daring.

Gender
The challenges to conventional gender norms in Dragon Pearl are casual and persistent. Early in the book, Min describes how foxes traditionally choose to be female, but her young cousin Manshik "insisted on being male" like Jun, and no one gave him a hard time about it. Like, I cannot emphasize how cool this is: the foxes choose their genders! Which may go some way towards explaining how easily Min adjusts when her infiltration of the ship on which her brother served requires her to take on the form of a dead male cadet. She is initially uncomfortable with his height and deeper voice (no mention is made of the genitalia situation, this is a children's book), but it doesn't take very long for her to get used to it, or to responding to "he" and "him". In a book as trans-aware as this, it is unlikely that Lee did not consider the possibility of ongoing dysphoria. So I think it's reasonable to read Min as someways genderfluid, as someone for whom, as a result of both her species and individual inclination, femaleness is a deliberate, comfortable choice, but not an absolute necessity. Min's form is mutable, and we are told in so many words that turning into a boy is not inherently any stranger for her than turning into a cup or a table.
Elsewhere, it is not necessary to search and interpret. Min's new identity as Cadet Jang comes preloaded with two friends, Hanuel and Sujin. Sujin is a Dokkaebi, a goblin, and the nametag on their uniform indicates that they should be addressed with gender neutral pronouns. It is not clear whether the "they" pronouns are a goblin thing or a Sujin thing, but what stands out here is first of all, there's a nonbinary character, and second of all, the military in this world put everyone's pronouns on their name tags.
No fuss is made over any of this. Nonbinary pronouns and gender as a personal choice are all as nonchalantly inherent to Min's worldview as dragons, spaceships, and her own versatile shapeshifting abilities.

Magic and Science
One area in which Dragon Pearl does have a contemporary tradition with which to be in conversation is the blending of science fiction and fantasy elements. It harkens to the Young Wizards books and Artemis Fowl, both series directed at about the same age group, in the seamless, culturally normalized integration of magic into technology and vis versa, and the coexistence of different species who each related to the magic, and the technology, a little differently.
Most of the overt magic belongs to the foxes, goblins, dragons, ghosts, and presumably celestial maidens, although we do not see enough of the lattermost to have any real sense of their capabilities, but the functioning of the spaceships relies on the flow of "mystic energy" (explicitly analogous to gi in the human body) through their meridians, which can be messed up by ghosts or bad luck as well as by mechanical glitches or physical damage.
There is not such explicit integration of magic into every aspect of the technology. The laundry robots are just laundry robots, and aside from relying on the mystic energy of the ship, there's nothing magical about the onboard hydroponics, although they are receptive to being blessed by Hanuel's dragon magic.

Rick Riordan Presents
Rick Riordan Presents is an imprint of Disney-Hyperion Publishing, with the specific objective of spotlighting books from marginalized authors that Rick Riordan, and his editor, think will appeal to fans of his work. So far, Dragon Pearl is the only book from this imprint that I've read, but it absolutely fits that mission statement, and I felt like I needed to take a second to talk about how cool I think this project is. A successful white dude author putting his literal seal of approval on books by more marginalized authors that he thinks his readers will like, and thereby not only helping further their careers but get those books in front of his young fans - allowing his readers who don't look like him to see themselves at the center of stories, and encouraging those who do to immerse themselves in identities and perspectives other than their own - is exactly how publishing should work, and I would like to see a lot more of this kind of thing.

Conclusion
Dragon Pearl is as groundbreaking as it is necessary. It's queer, it's innovative, and it's just really cool. Come for the exiting space adventure, stay for the deeper politics and nonchalant faith in the reader's ability to handle complex topics without a lot of handholding and methodical explanation. Also it's a really quick read, because children's book, so if you're in that kind of "This sounds neat and I would love to read more, but I have such limited time and energy" place, know that this won't cost you very much of either.
Seriously: Read. This. Book.

Update 12-16-2019



To the surprise of absolutely no one, I fell far short of my goal of drafting 60 handwritten pages during NaNo. I managed 13. That makes this the least productive NaNo on record since I started doing it this way, but it's still nonzero progress. I will be updating all the trackers soon to reflect it.
I am pretty close to done with the freelance assignment. This is an exciting new source of financial stress, but it should mean I have more time to work on my own stuff, at least until I find something else to replace the income and the associated massive time sink.
One of the books I had to read for that project was Maps of Time by David Christian, and I would strongly recommend it for writers of second world fantasy or science fiction set on other planets. A 101 introduction to "big history", it covers everything from the big bang to the present day in lightly sketched detail, focusing more on humans after they come on the scene some five chapters in. It's a very good reference point for working out what might change in a world that is "mostly like our world but", and a great model of in what kind of depth it makes sense to build the different areas of history in your world. Because it focuses on the how and why of large scale changes, it can also be a good frame of reference for looking at how it would change things if something like the domestication of horses happened earlier, later, or not at all, or evaluating them impact of, say, readily available healing magic.
I've read a fair number of fiction books as well. Ink, by Alice Broadway, is a NaNo novel in a world where everyone in the protagonist's culture has a bunch of tattoos, some official and some chosen, laying out basically everything about their lives for the world to see. It's casually diverse, the actual premise gets an appropriate amount of use and detail, and it manages to avoid all but one of the most frustrating tropes of Dystopian YA, although just once I'd like to see a Manipulative Status Quo Mentor who's a man, and a Sincere Resistance Mentor who's a woman. (Some stories, like Flawed, do have female Manipulative Resistance Mentors, but that's not the same). It's a fast read, and the book ends with the main character just 110% burning her life down, so I'm looking forward to the sequel, which is already out, I just don't have it from the library yet.
The other book I wanted to talk about is Tempests and Slaughter, which I'm only just now getting around to, but have been looking forward to with some trepidation since I found out it was going to be a thing. It's good. I mean, it ain't Will Of the Empress, but what is? And it's not Trickster's Choice, or worse yet battle magic, which was honestly the bigger concern. Pierce doesn't have a great track record with either writing events previously alluded to or Tortall books set outside Tortall, but she does just fine with both here, and is clearly putting some effort into addressing some of the more problematic aspects of her earlier work in this setting. There's gay people and polyamory and an extremely unsubtle gifted education analogy, all of which I am here for.
Some of Arram's early side quests, including caring for a baby bird and and preparing medicine during a plague, are obvious reuse of plot elements from Circle of Magic, but the effect is more comforting familiarity than lazy formulaism. Similarly, Ozorne's dynamic with Chioké seems deliberately reminiscent of Thom's with Rodger (minus, so far, any sign of inappropriate sexual behavior), but I suspect this is an invitation for informed readers to catch some clues, and it could still totally be a red herring. For this one, I will have to wait until the next book comes out.
Thank you so much to everyone who's stuck with me through this incredibly unreliable few months. Be gay, do crimes, and read ALL the things!